Aotearoa NZ: People power kills controversial bill

April 16, 2025
Issue 
protesting the treaty principles bill
Opponents saw the bill as a tool to undermine the status of M膩ori and mobilised in their thousands against it. Photo: RNZ

The controversial Treaty Principles bill has been defeated after the people of Aotearoa New Zealand spoke out against it in record numbers.

The bill was put to parliament for its second reading on April 10, where it was voted down 112 votes to 11. The only MPs to vote in favour of it were from ACT, the libertarian party that introduced it.

This followed a six-month public consultation period in which a record-breaking number of people had their say about the divisive bill.

Submissions were overwhelmingly opposed to it, with 90% speaking against it and just 8% supporting it. Two percent of submissions provided no definitive view.

The justice select committee charged with managing the process received more than 300,000 written submissions 鈥 the highest number ever for a parliamentary bill. They also heard 80 hours of oral submissions from 529 people over the course of 5 weeks.

The committee ultimately recommended that the bill not proceed further than its second reading.

Their report stated that common themes amongst opponents to the bill were its inconsistency with the Treaty/te Tiriti, the possible negative effect on social cohesion, and flaws in the bill development process.

The controversial bill sought to "redefine" the principles of Aotearoa鈥檚 founding document, the Treaty of Waitangi/te Tiriti o Waitangi.

ACT鈥檚 leader David Seymour claims M膩ori are afforded special rights and privileges due to the way the Treaty/te Tiriti has been interpreted. 聽

However, opponents see the bill as a tool to undermine the status of M膩ori as the indigenous people of Aotearoa.

The bill was one of ACT鈥檚 flagship campaign policies leading up to the 2023 general election in which they received just 9% of the public鈥檚 vote.

Despite this, they were able to push the contentious bill through as part of their agreement with the National party, which they formed a coalition government with along with NZ First.

In response to the select committee鈥檚 report, Seymour claimed the result reflected a country that is 鈥渄ivided on [the] issue鈥, even though the majority of submissions were opposed to the bill.

After the bill鈥檚 defeat he posted on social media that his party 鈥渨ill never give up鈥 on the idea, vowing that 鈥渂etween now and the next election, we鈥檒l be showing the next steps".

Prime Minister Christopher Luxon was not in Parliament for the second reading, a move that Labour leader Chris Hipkins called 鈥渃owardly鈥. Luxon blamed his absence on scheduling conflicts.

In a speech before the vote, Hipkins said the proposed legislation would forever "be a stain on our country."

Te Pati M膩ori (Maori Party) MP Hana-Rawhiti Maipi-Clarke caught the world鈥檚 attention last year when she tore up a copy of the bill and led a haka in parliament to protest against it.

In her speech, Maipi-Clarke highlighted that the process has proven Aotearoa is not divided on the issue: 鈥淭his bill hasn鈥檛 been stopped; this bill has been absolutely annihilated.

鈥淲e are not divided, but united 鈥 This ignited an emotion that echoed with all walks of life, all races, all ages and all genders across the world.鈥

As the bill died, those present in parliament cheered and applauded.聽 ACT鈥檚 MPs departed quickly, before the remaining lawmakers and those in the public gallery performed a waiata 鈥 a traditional M膩ori song 鈥 in celebration.

You need 麻豆传媒, and we need you!

麻豆传媒 is funded by contributions from readers and supporters. Help us reach our funding target.

Make a One-off Donation or choose from one of our Monthly Donation options.

Become a supporter to get the digital edition for $5 per month or the print edition for $10 per month. One-time payment options are available.

You can also call 1800 634 206 to make a donation or to become a supporter. Thank you.