Abbott gov't the most pro-Israel ever

August 9, 2014
Issue 
Tony Abbot with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.

As civilian casualties climb from its brutal assault on Gaza, Israel has met growing condemnation for the carnage from human rights groups and many governments.

In Latin America, the response has been especially strong. Since Israel began its assault a month ago, El Savador, Chile, Peru, Brazil and Ecuador have withdrawn their ambassadors in protest.

Bolivia has filed a case with the United Nations against Israel鈥檚 鈥渃rimes against humanity鈥, with President Evo Morales on July 30 鈥渨e are declaring [Israel] a terrorist state鈥.

On the same day, the bodies of 16 people were pulled from the rubble of a United Nations school sheltering Palestinian refugees that Israeli forces had bombed. it was 鈥渢he second time in a week that a UN school housing refugees has been hit, and the sixth in two weeks鈥.

On the same day in Jerusalem, Australia鈥檚 government sent a very different message to Israel. As keynote speaker at the Australia-Israel-UK Leadership Dialogue, Australian education minister : 鈥淚srael is the beacon of freedom and liberty in the Middle East.鈥

Pyne said Australia and Israel were 鈥渢wo sister nations believing in the same thing ... we regard Israel and Australia as sister countries with the same value systems and we want to show our support for that system here in the Middle East鈥.

Pyne stressed that Australia was 鈥済ood friends鈥 with Israel and 鈥済ood friends visit their friends in tough times鈥.

He said he was in Israel 鈥渂ecause Australians love freedom鈥. But the 鈥渇reedom鈥 he has in mind does not extend to Palestinians under a near-50 year military occupation long under international law or to Gazans subject to the .

Rather, Pyne offered the Australian government鈥檚 unqualified support to Israel: 鈥淲henever there has been a congregation of freedom-loving nations versus non freedom-loving nations, Australia has always been prepared to be in the fight and always on the right side.

鈥淎nd that鈥檚 how we view the State of Israel, that we are on the right side.鈥

Pyne鈥檚 comments are not surprising. Since it came to power last year, Tony Abbott鈥檚 Coalition government has strengthened Australia鈥檚 official support for .

In November, the government reversed Australia鈥檚 previous opposition to the in the Occupied Territories.

At the UN, Australia abstained from motions calling on Israel to end settlement activity and to comply with the Geneva Convention. Foreign Minister Julie Bishop said the change 鈥渞eflected the government's concern that Middle East resolutions should be balanced鈥.

In June, the Abbott government announced that it would no longer refer to the Occupied Territories as 鈥渙ccupied鈥. Attorney-General on June 5: 鈥淭he description of areas which are the subject of negotiations in the course of the peace process, by reference to historical events is unhelpful.

鈥淭he description of East Jerusalem as 鈥榦ccupied East Jerusalem鈥 is a term freighted with pejorative implications, which is neither appropriate, nor useful.

鈥淚t should not and will not be the practice of the Australian government to describe areas of negotiation in such judgmental language.鈥

With this change, Australia became the only government outside of Israel that does not recognise the obvious: that Israel occupies Palestinian land. The position is than Israel鈥檚 closest ally, the United States, can accept.

The Australian government鈥檚 concern for avoiding 鈥渏udgmental language鈥 and the 鈥減ejorative implications鈥 of some words does not extend to Palestinian groups like Hamas, which is the democratically elected government of the Palestinian Territories.

on July 17: 鈥淭he Australian government has listed Hamas as a terrorist organisation pursuant to UN Security Council Resolution 1373, which deals with the prevention and suppression of terrorist acts.鈥

In this case, Bishop鈥檚 rhetoric appears to contradict the government鈥檚 existing policy: until now, the Australian government had listed only Hamas鈥 military wing 鈥 the al-Qassam Brigades 鈥 as a terrorist group.

Asked by 3AW radio if the Australian government backed Israel鈥檚 ground assault on Gaza, : 鈥淲e certainly support Israel鈥檚 right to exist. We support Israel鈥檚 right to self-defence and we deplore the attacks on Israel from Gaza ...

鈥淎ll I know is that Israel is regularly rocketed from Gaza. That shouldn鈥檛 happen.鈥

Statements like this from Australia鈥檚 pro-Israel politicians are hardly new and echo the same, tired talking points: Israel is not the aggressor, it鈥檚 defending itself; Israel is not committing acts of terror, it鈥檚 fighting terror; Israel is not an apartheid state, it鈥檚 a beacon of democracy.

But despite the essential continuity with the line of past Australian governments, there has been a shift in attitude under Abbott. Australia now has the most fanatically pro-Zionist government in its history.

[This article first appeared at .]

麻豆传媒 Weekly on Facebook and on Twitter.

You need 麻豆传媒, and we need you!

麻豆传媒 is funded by contributions from readers and supporters. Help us reach our funding target.

Make a One-off Donation or choose from one of our Monthly Donation options.

Become a supporter to get the digital edition for $5 per month or the print edition for $10 per month. One-time payment options are available.

You can also call 1800 634 206 to make a donation or to become a supporter. Thank you.