Venezuela: Right-wing provokes violence in time-worn practice

February 12, 2014
Issue 
Violent opposition protest in Merida. February 11. Photo by Tamara Pearson/Venezuelanalysis.com.

History repeats itself. The time-worn tactic of the dominant class that controls the spread of information is to provoke violence and then blame it on the enemy, usually those who struggle for change.

Nero did it when he burned down much of Rome and blamed it on the Christians. Similarly, US newspaper publisher William Randolph Hearst used the sinking of the USS Maine in 1898 to create war fervour that led to war with Spain.

Hitler ordered the burning of the Reichstag and blamed it on the Communists. He also had Germans dressed as Poles attack German troops to justify the invasion that began World War II.

The Gulf of Tonkin incident played out a similar scenario to justify US escalating its war on Vietnam. And George Bush Sr. used the same tactic to justify the invasion of Panama in 1989.

In Venezuela, this tactic has been used umpteen times throughout the past 15 years. The most infamous incident was on April 11, 2002 when shootings by snipers on demonstrators justified the US-backed coup against then-president Hugo Chavez.

But the opposition in Venezuela has used this trick over and over again. During the general strike of 2002-3, a woman physically attacked a National Guardsman and then the opposition showed (out of context) the part where the guard pushed the woman to the ground.

In another incident, a woman protester in Caracas approached National Guard members and spat on one of them. The private media then just showed the reaction of one of the guardsmen, who pushed the instigator to the ground, again taking the incident out of context.

It turned out that the instigator was a city councillor belonging to the right-wing opposition.

Today the same thing is happening and the private media is promoting the same deceit. Opposition demonstrators have created havoc in the centre of Caracas and elsewhere, burning public buildings, using firearms after attacking the house of the governor in the state of Tachira.

The announced intention of Leopoldo Lopez, an opposition leader who has organised these protests, is to overthrow the government. He says it publicly.

And yet the media are making it seem as if the violence is the work of motorcyclists, supposedly on behalf of the Chavista government of Nicolas Maduro! (These same Chavista 鈥渉ordes鈥 were blamed for the violence at the time of the 2002 coup, in fact opposition newspaper El Nacional called the Chavistas 鈥渓umpen鈥.)

Common sense tells you that the government has nothing to gain by promoting random violence. Furthermore there is tons of footage showing that the violence perpetrated by the opposition protesters.

But the media, true to form, both in Venezuela and abroad, use all their ingenuity to convince people, sometimes in subtle ways, that Chavista 鈥渉ordes鈥 are behind the violence. Sometimes all it takes is common sense to know what is going on.

[Professor Steve Ellner has taught at the Universidad de Oriente in Puerto La Cruz, Venezuela, since 1977. He is the author of many books on Venezuelan politics.]


Comments

FWIW, almost all historians agree that Nero did not set the fire nor order it, and there are basically ZERO historian who think that Hitler or any Nazi's were behind the Reichstag fire, although of course they milked it for all it was worth.
But Paolo: who were the guests at Nero's feast with lights and all? Can you watch the documentary "Nero's Guest": Farmers' Suicide in India. By P. Sainath, a journalist. We will all be enlightened by your insight into how Tacitus wrtoe about this part of History. -bougnoul

You need 麻豆传媒, and we need you!

麻豆传媒 is funded by contributions from readers and supporters. Help us reach our funding target.

Make a One-off Donation or choose from one of our Monthly Donation options.

Become a supporter to get the digital edition for $5 per month or the print edition for $10 per month. One-time payment options are available.

You can also call 1800 634 206 to make a donation or to become a supporter. Thank you.